Host: Dr Robert Hungerford (H), Guest Expert: Dr Matias Yudi (Y)
(H) This is unit 8 of 10 on heart valve disease. In this unit we are going to explain how aortic stenosis typically progresses, at what stage your doctor will consider treatment, what the main treatment options are, how risks, benefits and recovery can differ between people or procedures, and some questions to ask your heart team about which option is best for you. Dr. Yudi, can you please refresh our listeners on how aortic stenosis worsens progressively over time and at what stage you would want to start treatment?
(Y) Aortic stenosis is just a stiffening of that aortic valve and that gets worse as we age, but it gets worse very slowly. The most important thing is to get a diagnosis of aortic stenosis and then follow that through and be on the lookout for symptoms such as breathlessness when you're walking, exercise intolerance, chest pain or feeling dizzy and lightheaded. And also, you'll be having ultrasounds over a period of time, echocardiograms, which will also look at the valve and seeing how the heart is coping with that restriction. And when we've got symptoms and we've got markers that the valve is severe, that is when it is time to intervene. Before then, you're not going to get great benefit out of this at some risk. And if you pick the right spot, you'll have minimal risks with the maximum benefit, both in terms of symptoms, so you'll get better, and also you will live normally without any treatment, unfortunately patients do very poorly over the next one to two years.
(H) Okay, so we've talked about how aortic stenosis is a structural issue and so the main treatment is aortic valve replacement. What are the options and how do they differ?
(Y) Aortic stenosis needs to have that aortic valve replaced. And traditionally we'd only do this with surgery, which would mean a cut in the front of your chest, open heart surgery, take out the valve and put a new one in. What's great now in 2026 is there's been huge development in technology over the last two decades. And now we have transcatheter aortic valve replacement, which is minimally invasive, we put a tube in the femoral artery or a blood vessel in your groin and we're able to feed the valve from the leg to the heart and get you a new valve that way. And that's revolutionised the way that we can treat this condition because this can now be done under sedation. So, you don't need to have a general anaesthetic. You don't have to be intubated. You don't go to ICU. And most of our patients go home within 24 to 48 hours. So, this has been a game changer, particularly when we think about the patients that are getting treated, which usually tend to be elderly and who do not want to have major upfront risks from any more invasive procedure, such as open-heart surgery.
(H) And who makes the decision as to whether a surgical aortic valve replacement or a transcatheter aortic valve replacement is most appropriate?
(Y) That is a sensational question, the key to how well patients do is that they become part of a heart valve team. They have the whole work up and then they get discussed in a big multidisciplinary team meeting where we ascertain what are the best treatments for that patient. Like you said, based on their age, their health, their anatomy and their personal preference. And we look both at the risks now and also for the rest of their lives. And that's how we come up with a conclusion whether that patient would do better with something minimally invasive or something more extensive, like surgical aortic valve replacement, that may have other benefits for them down the track.
(H) Let's divide it into those two surgeries now and I'll get you to explain each one individually. So, can you let the audience know what happens during a surgical aortic valve replacement first?
(Y) This is the traditional way that we use to treat severe aortic stenosis. So, this is performed by cardiac surgeons, and this is done in an operating theatre under general anaesthetic, so you are completely asleep during this procedure, and you have a lung machine breathing for you. The surgeon then opens the chest, the breastbone at the front of your chest, and they can see the heart directly and then you go on bypass. So, you have a machine pumping blood to the rest of the body. The surgeon removes the valve and then he puts a new one in place and stitches it at the right place between the left ventricle and the aorta. And then they close up your chest. You tend to go to ICU for a day or two, and then you come down to a step-down ward. And you're usually home within seven to ten days.
(H) Okay. And what about recovery? So, what's the recovery time? What does that look like with the open chest surgery or the surgical aortic valve replacement?
(Y) Yeah, look, it's a bigger upfront risk investment. I think it is important to know that you do spend a day or two in the intensive care unit. Then you still have a big wound in your chest and that takes about three months to heal. So, during that time you cannot do excessive lifting because you don't want that breastbone to be moving and you want it to heal as well as possible. You tend not to feel quite yourself for a good four weeks. But after that, you do get your strength back and you start doing normal activities. And by three months, you're completely back to normal.
(H) Now, you talked about this other procedure, the TAVI procedure. Again, can you walk us through what actually happens with that procedure and what is the expected recovery look like?
(Y) TAVI is very different to a surgical valve replacement. You'll feel in a much more relaxed environment because you'll be awake. You'll be talking to the anaesthetist who will be giving you some light sedation. Your interventional cardiologist will be there, and they'll be performing the procedure. They'll put local anaesthetic over your femoral artery, which is the artery in the groin of your leg, and then they put in a catheter or a small tube inside that blood vessel, and that would lead to the aortic valve. Using an x-ray machine, we take different photos, different pictures, and then we release the valve in the right place, and the valves that we have push your old valve aside, so they have a stent frame, and inside there you have very beautiful leaflets that are very thin and mobile, not the heavily calcified leaflets that you have in severe aortic stenosis, and they start to function straight away. Once the valve is deployed and we see it functioning well, then we remove that tube that we use to deliver the valve, and we put a little stitch in the leg and you're out of the interventional cardiology suite. And that usually tends to take about 60 minutes. You go back to a cardiology ward and the only annoying thing of this is that you tend to lie flat on your back for about four to six hours. You don't want to have any major bleeding problems for when those tubes went in. But you're usually out for the next big meal and you're walking around that night and the next day you have an ultrasound of your heart, an echocardiogram, you get a blood test. And if everything looks good, we're pretty comfortable at letting you at home at that point. The recovery is, I encourage my patients to get up and about and do normal walking. For the first week I don't want them to be doing any heavy lifting or any running, just so that wound in their leg heals. But after that, I'm very, very happy for them to do everything and really test out the new valve. And they should feel a lot more energy and a significant decrease in their symptoms because they're no longer pumping blood through a very narrowed calcified valve.
(H) Dr. Yudi, are patients sedated and how heavily are they sedated?
(Y) One of the great advantages of the TAVI procedure is that it is no longer done under general anaesthetic. So, you don't have the risks associated with that and you don't have the aftermath of general anaesthetic as well. But in saying that, you are sedated so you feel comfortable, you feel sleepy, and most importantly, you don't feel pain of the procedure, the anaesthetist gives you something for that through the drip in your arm, and also the cardiologist puts plenty of local anaesthetic in the leg where they're going to put the tubes and deliver the valve from. So even though you may hear some things, you're not living through the procedure bit by bit, which is very reassuring, although some patients do love to know what's going on. But the key is for you to be comfortable and to get a great outcome.
(H) Dr. Yudi, I know that sometimes it can be challenging to know whether a TAVI or a SAVA is the most appropriate procedure. And we hear about some new technology and with the TAVI interventions, and we lean towards that. Why is SAVA still offered, the surgical procedure still offered? And is that sometimes the better or the preferred procedure than TAVI? Or should every patient be looking to have this TAVI procedure?
(Y) Rob, that is a sensational question and it's something that we encounter from patients all the time. If you had to choose between having a big cut down your sternum, being in an ICU, not being right for three months versus coming in and out in 24 hours, you will choose the minimal invasive approach every time, and this is why we've got these heart teams, is that we are not looking at things in isolation. We want to work out what is the best thing for you, for the patient, both now and in the future, based on so many factors, including your age, what other heart abnormalities you may have, what other risk factors you have, what other comorbidities you have. So the treatment for, let's say, my grandma who's 85 with severe aortic stenosis, we want her to get to 90 and beyond, minimally invasive, is completely different to what we think about when we've got a 55-year-old with a bicuspid aortic valve where the TAVI hasn't been tested in this kind of condition. So even though they both have severe aortic stenosis, they're completely different people outside of their aortic stenosis, and our goals completely different. That is why it's so important to be part of a great heart valve team that has your best interest at hand, both for your best outcome now, but also into the future, taking into account so many other factors. And sometimes, unfortunately, the best long-term solution for a patient is to have open heart surgery.
(H) And Dr. Yudi, are there any new medications or medication changes that happen after either of these two procedures?
(Y) Usually there's no major changes. If you are on a blood thinner for other reasons, for example, if you have atrial fibrillation and you need a blood thinner for that, then you go back on that normal blood thinner. If you're not on any blood thinners at all, you tend to go on aspirin, 100 milligrams, a little baby aspirin. And that is the only new thing. But most people are on some type of blood thinner for other conditions before they get to us.
(H) Now, I mean, patients probably have lots of questions when they're confronted with aortic stenosis and potential surgery. What are some good questions about treatment that listeners can ask their cardiologist about the procedures and about the workup for this and the recovery as well?
(Y) Yeah, look, I think we've touched on a few of those already, but I think as a patient, it is important to really take your own view and your own preferences into account, and make sure you have that at the forefront of the questions that you have for your treating team. More generically, I think you need to ask what are the risks with the interventions, both short and long term, and how long the valves are going to last for. And I think that's very important if you're a younger patient. It's very different if you're in your 80s to in your 50s because you may need multiple interventions in your lifetime. The benefits are really, really important for you to ask and also to have clear in your head that you're doing this for symptoms but also to live longer and there's different alternatives as we've talked about between surgery and minimally invasive transcatheter aortic valve implantation. Ideally, you would have gone through a heart team, a very good heart team that does a lot of surgery and lots of TAVI and have experience with multiple valves, so they're able to choose the best treatment and the best valve for you. It is important to have a good idea of the small risks associated with both procedures and a timeline of what recovery looks like. And then lastly, look, we do consent all patients for a blood transfusion, whether you're having surgery or minimally invasive TAVI. And if you for some reason, do not want to have a blood transfusion, it's important to make that very, very clear. And if you have any concerns, and something hasn't been explained to you properly, remember that you're the patient and you're the one who has to undertake this. If you feel uncomfortable, feel free to get a second opinion or ask for another appointment to discuss other issues in more detail or do your own research and then come back with a list of questions with both you and your family so you can make sure that you're all on board.
(H) Thank you, Dr. Yudi, for going through the surgical options that our patients have when it comes to aortic stenosis. Listeners can visit the resources listed in this module to find out further information. Next up, we'll be looking ahead to life after treatment.
Voice Over
The information presented in this program is for educational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. It is not intended to replace consultation with a qualified healthcare professional. Always seek the advice of your doctor or other qualified healthcare professional with any questions regarding a medical condition, or before making changes to your treatment.